Normally the hype surrounding a film magnifies my inevitable disappointment with it or builds unrealistic expectations in story/plot/characterization. For the most part, the super hero films of the past decade have fallen into that trap (at least for me). I think that of all of them, I enjoyed
Iron Man the most, but that, too, joined the ranks of "super" mediocrity in its sequels. And
Captain America was decent, even enjoyable, but nothing to really write (split infinitive!) home about. Needless to say, I was a little skittish when I heard the announcement for
The Avengers a couple of years ago. After months of teaser trailers and a week of hearing how awesome
The Avengers is, I just had to go. I was going to go anyway (JOSS WHEDON!), but I pushed up the time table a bit because of the universal acclaim (from both critics and the public) it had received. And it did not disappoint. In fact, it exceeded expectations.
Story - Solid with no plot holes (at least that's what I noticed on the first viewing). Whedon wove six disparate character threads and arcs together rather artfully. I envy his writing ability.
Dialogue - Fit the characters to a "T." Whedon really took the time to understand the characters and how they would interact with each other. The best lines belong to Tony Stark, of course! But each character has a few good witty jabs and sarcastic zingers. Witty banter is always a plus.
Characters - Awesome. They were true to their comic book heritage. Their interactions with each other were so well thought-out. I know that a lot of the characters (Thor, Captain America, and Iron Man) had already been cast in previous movies...but the additions of Black Widow, Hawkeye and the recast Hulk actually added to it. They weren't just fluff. And what a great choice in ensemble casting! Robert Downey Jr. (Tony Stark), Chris Evans (Captain America), Mark Ruffalo (Hulk), Chris Hemsworth (Thor), Scarlett Johansson (Black Widow), Jeremy Renner (Hawkeye), Tom Hiddleston (Loki) and Samuel L. Jackson (Nick Fury) - thank you for making your characters believable!
Visuals - ILM + Weta + Digital Domain + myriad VFX companies = pristine VFX work. I think you did a marvelous job. Motion seemed realistic. And the explosions weren't the main focus, like a Michael Bay movie. The action avoided excess and didn't slide into sensory overload. FINALLY! Thank you.
Themes - Let's see. Typical superhero themes = sacrifice, team work, good vs. evil, winning against impossible odds, blah blah blah. But you know what? I don't mind because, deep down inside (but not too deep), I want to see all of that in a superhero flick. It's really the brilliant execution that prevented this movie from feeling cheesetastic. Whedon gives us the same thing (those themes), but completely different, and that's why he's original. He's not trying too hard, like everybody else. If your first goal is to be original, guess what? You won't be original. Just focus on telling a great story with good themes and the rest will flow.
Also, this is a super hero movie that can appeal to everybody, not just comic book nerds. But it does satisfy the geekier portion of the moviegoer population. Basically, everyone wins.
Joss Whedon provided a breath of fresh air to a genre that, in my opinion, had become rather watered-down and, well, lame.
The Avengers lived up to everything I could possibly want in the superhero genre without being cliche, which is a feat few writers in modern Hollywood are capable of accomplishing. Of course, I expect nothing less from Whedon, who's given us such wonderful and much-beloved shows as
Buffy The Vampire Slayer, Firefly, and
Dollhouse. He's definitely earned the considerable following he's gained over the past two decades and I am so incredibly happy that he's finally getting mainstream recognition - hopefully we'll see his hand in many more projects (after earning $1B at the box office, I damn well better see more of him!).
The Avengers 2? Yes, please!