Showing posts with label The Great Tradition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Great Tradition. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

TGT #2 - Xenophon & Underwater Basket Weaving

OK folks - it's that time of the month again, when I make myself feel incredibly stupid by publishing some half-baked thoughts on the ingenious musings of far more brilliant men. So what didn't Xenophon do?  His resume puts mine to shame: soldier, historian, essayist, Athenian veteran of the Peloponnesian War.  Why Maddie?  Why must you do this to yourself?  Because it's about the higher things!  And they scream out to me on a fairly regular basis.  Unfortunately, my friends, this will probably not end up being a particularly coherent essay.  Greek writers tend to do that to me.  Where will I end up this time?  Well, let's get on with it...

The early Greeks seem to be obsessed about this thing they call (or at least our translator calls) "excellence."  I have a vague notion of what they are getting at there, but I'll move on to other things.  When talking of Socrates, Xenophon starts off with this:
"Thus he [Socrates] would often say he was 'in love'; but clearly his heart was not set on those who were fair to outward view, but those whose souls excelled in goodness.  These excellent beings he recognized by their quickness to learn whatever subject they studied, ability to remember what they learned, and desire for every kind of knowledge on which depend good management of a household and estate and tactful dealing with men and the affairs of men.  For education would make such beings not only happy in themselves, and successful in the management of their households, but capable of conferring happiness on their fellow-men and on states alike" (TGT 30).  
He seems to be linking education and happiness.  Education isn't always rainbows and fuzzy bunnies - it opens your eyes to some of the bleaker aspects of human nature and the human condition.  However, a true education sets your mind ablaze and lifts you up to an entirely new world of understanding.  And in that you can be happy.  You constantly hunger for more and more to fill that insatiable intellectual appetite.  I've experienced this at Hillsdale - once you get a taste of it, you never go back.  All of the sudden, you come back home for Christmas and get really excited about receiving The Great Tradition as your present rather than a Best Buy gift card.  Also, if "conferring happiness" means "pass down what you have learned," then I am all for that.  But I'm not sure that's what Xenophon is going for there...

On the next page (TGT 31), Xenophon launches into some argument with a pompous ass about his indebtedness to the past for his knowledge.  Woot!  Way to go, Xenophon!  Also, on page 37, he tells us about how Socrates urged his followers to be well-rounded.  Yay for the liberal arts!  Huzzah!

There's some other stuff and then we hit 35, a page that contains the infamous words "know thyself."  This is probably one of the most misquoted phrases EVER (besides "ideas have consequences.")  The modern world likes to twist it around into empty phrases like that inane Disney message of "be you true self and who you were truly mean to be (a rock star, duh!) and everything will be super-special awesome!"  What the heck does any of that claptrap mean?  I'm sorry, but Miley Cyrus/Hannah Montana and Selena Gomez do not impress me with their "selfness."  To the Greeks, it meant know your abilities and limitations.  It's an important self-examination that we like to gloss over in modernity.  We often tell people that they should refuse to be held back by any limitations, even ones inherent in their nature/being.  Or we're told that our abilities are way more amazing than they actually are.  This leads to a lot of frustration and anger, especially with kids in my generation who were given participation trophies for underwater basket weaving and then told that all of us could be rock stars or corporate executives.  We have built up our self-esteem at the cost of taking an honest look in the mirror.  We ignore what we really are so we can be something we're not.  Basically, Socrates' two-word phrase warns that same pompous ass against boasting.  We boast much about nothing these days....and are the unhappier for it. 

Did any of what I just wrote make sense?  Don't care - must. publish. article.  OK - enough incoherent babbling.  I'm going to finish off with another theme Xenophon seemed particularly fond of: don't specialize - it's bad.  The End.

Saturday, October 29, 2011

TGT #1 - The Platonic Form of Plato

OK, Plato. You're goin' down...sort of.

Actually, I think he may have owned me on this one. If I were to reduce the great minds of the ancient Western World to dishes at dinner, Plato would be the equivalent to eating raw beets - it's good for you, your mom always puts way more on your plate than you would like, and you normally don't go out of your way to eat it. Aristotle is like salad with dressing. Still healthy, but more palatable with some Italian or Caesar. Cicero is like having a steak. Mmmm...Cicero. (Actually, I might rethink that analogy later. Too late. I ain't deletin' it now.)

Back on topic. Argh...Plato. I have to admit that I have been having a hard time trying to come up with the content of this particular post. It has been torturing me for a good month at this point. I normally don't procrastinate this much. Seriously, I'm normally never this close to a deadline. This is a new low for me. I think I'm about to have an academic-existential meltdown ...*hyperventilating*... (realization that I'm not going to be graded ... but I will be judged) ... *breathe* ...

There's almost too much to discuss. But there are a few things that stick out, like the attributes of a true learner: truthfulness, lack of illiberality, pleasure/delight in learning, a good memory. Most importantly, a student must have "a naturally well-proportioned, gracious mind, which will move spontaneously towards the true being of everything" (TGT 11).

And then I hit the "Allegory of the Cave" section. No venture into Plato's world is complete without it. And as soon as I began reading the words (NOSTALGIA ALERT!), I was immediately transported back to Western Heritage class some day in the first semester of my Freshman year. Amanda and I were sitting on the right-hand side of the classroom. All of us were looking at a sketch Dr. G had just made on the black board, a crude mock-up of a cave with two stick figures looking at shadows projected by a fire. I reproduced it below, except this time I decided to make it all fancy with color 'n stuff in Adobe Illustrator (yes, I spent 30 minutes distracting myself with this side project to avoid saying anything substantive about Plato. Check out that gradient on the fire. So fancy!).


Now for something completely different...SUBSTANCE! Another thing ("thing" isn't a very academic word, isn't it?) that stood out to me was Plato's take on the purpose of education. For Plato, "knowledge is to know the nature of being" (TGT 7). During the Allegory of the Cave, Plato began echoing Dr. Arnn [ :) ] about how the world of knowledge to points toward "the Good, the True, and the Beautiful" (Hillsdalian joke). Moving into the Laws, Plato asserts that education is a lifelong pursuit of excellence and goodness. Consistency should be valued over change, or else future generations will never learn to revere that which has been passed down to them. Plato also believed that the whole state (men and women) ought to be educated--how can a state be whole if it is not made up of whole men and women? He recognized how unruly children could become and insisted that we must take special care in "the training of our children, directing their natures, and always turning them to good according to the law" (TGT 26). Plato was all over the place - I kind of have intellectual whiplash right now. It hurts.

Wow - I meandered around a bit, then got to the point in a fashion that lacked eloquence. Did that all make sense? Did it flow? Did I make an absolute fool of myself? Do I look like an ignoramus? Should I publish this tonight? (major wavering). Hmmm... (more indecisiveness). Oh hell, why not? Can't win them all...especially with Plato. Better luck next time!

Plato: 1
Maddie: 0 (but I did make an awesome stick drawing on a high-powered computer graphics program, so I get immunity and can go on to the next round. What now, Plato?).



NEXT EPISODE: Xenophon

Thursday, October 27, 2011

Blogging "The Great Tradition" - The Beginning

Richard M. Gamble, ed. The Great Tradition. Wilmington, DE: ISI Books, 2007.


(look for this badge on the side of each participating blog)


Years ago, Dr. Gamble assembled a hefty collection of "classic readings on what it means to be an educated human being" and it's been sitting on my shelf for 4 years, staring at me, making me feel guilty for never really making a dent in it. It was almost a yearly ritual - every Christmas, I'd pick it up, read through Plato, my brain would implode from overuse in the previous semester, and then I'd put it back on the shelf in defeat and sullenly return to watching classic movie marathons on Turner Classic Movies. This year, the cycle shall be broken! I (and several other bloggers) will be holding me accountable on this blog with monthly posts. I'm just about to kick off the "Blogging The Great Tradition" series and thought it appropriate to write an introductory post before delving right into it. (Actually, the only reason I am writing this right now is that I'm stalling - I'm still trying to figure out what the heck I'm going to write about Plato...sigh. So this is nothing more than me stalling. Nothing really brilliant here. At all. Fluff.)

[*opens VLC media player and chooses to play "Tradition" from Fiddler on the Roof for inspiration*]

Wait a second! I can write about Dr. Gamble's introduction. HA! (feigns being productive). If you read one of my introductions to the blog on the horizontal sidebar, you may have put two 'n two together that I got inspiration for my blog's name from this book's introduction...page xvi to be exact: "[This collection] will, I hope, inspire modern misfits who seek to initiate themselves and their students into an ancient way of teaching and learning much large than themselves, and who recognize that their task is chiefly formative rather than instrumental" (TGT xvi). It's about time I read this tome!

It's a great introduction. Evelyn Waugh, Herbert Butterfield and some fragments of wisdom from Philosophy of History class...what more could you ask for? Dr. Gamble basically sets us up to explore those aspects of a liberal education that make us complete human beings and very indebted to the past. My parents got him to sign a copy of the book (what would be my Christmas present for 2007), and in it he wrote "Give what you have received." I think that single, simple sentence gets to the root of it all, the very spirit of the Great Tradition itself. Thanks, Dr. G. We will try our best: Amanda at Penny Dreadfuls, Hannah at Fragments, and Liv at Unceasing Exploration (all aptly titled blogs).

I'll let Dr. G finish off this post: "The Great Tradition patiently endures, ready to speak on its own behalf, ready to challenge narrow prejudices, ready to examine those with the courage to be interrogated by it, ready to teach those who are willing to be made unfit for the modern world" (TGT, xix).