Tuesday, January 3, 2012

"The Adventures of Tintin: Secret of the Unicorn" (2011)


Was my War Horse review overly harsh?  Possibly.  Maybe.  Naaahhh.  Anyway, moving on.  Tintin ended up being my second favorite film of the year.  Is is going to win any major awards?  Probably not.  It didn't even get nominated for "Best Animated Feature" at the Academy (Am I a little peeved about that?  Hecks to the yizzle!).  I don't really care, though.  For the first time in a while, I felt that child-like wonder and amazement that's been missing from most of the movies I've seen in the past 10 years.  I grew up reading the books and watching the TV show adaptation re-runs on PBS and Nickelodeon with my mom.  If you aren't familiar with Tintin, stop reading this article right now and walk over to your local library.  Go. Now.

As always, Steven Moffat (plus two other writers I've never heard of before) wrote an excellent screenplay.  He's been on a role lately, what with Sherlock (BBC) and Doctor Who.  Can't wait to see what he comes up with next.  When I heard that Steven Spielberg and Peter Jackson were teaming up for this movie, I was a little worried about how the two directors would mesh.  But lo and behold, it turned out to be one of the best action adventure movies I've seen in the past decade.  Sure, it takes a lot of cues from Raiders of the Lost Ark, but it still manages to be faithful to the original "Tintin" stories. I feel like Spielberg sorta found his groove again (although War Horse puts that into question).

OK - there is one aspect in which War Horse trumps Tintin...the score.  John Williams produced a varied and emotional thematic structure for War Horse.  Tintin, on the other hand, ended up being a blended smoothie of everything Williams has ever composed (particularly his most recent scores).  You can hear some Indiana Jones, definitely some Harry Potter, and a hint of everything else.  I mean, the Tintin soundtrack was ok .  But because it seemed to lack originality or inspiration, it didn't really stick in my mind.  I have a test for movie scores.  If I don't notice it during the film, but then end up humming it on my way out of the theater, it did its job.  It enhanced the film emotionally without bludgeoning me over the head, but was distinctive enough to be remembered.  I would say Tintin enhanced the intensity of the action, much to the detriment of emotional depth.

The opening credits made me incredibly happy.  They were visually creative and did exactly what they were supposed to do - prepare you for the rollercoaster ride.  I would have enjoyed them more if the family in front of us hadn't lack MANNERS.  I hate it when people come in 2 minutes late to a movie and then proceed to open bags/boxes of candy (which then roll around and make even more noise).  Luckily, a quick "shut the heck up!" from me and problem solved:)

Finally, motion capture tech that I actually like!  A couple years back, Polar Express came off as just plain creepy.  Seriously, I had nightmares.  Not cool.  The tech has come a long way over the past several years.  And keeping the movie in the style of Herge's original cartoon made it all the more believable.  It forces you to suspend disbelief and just go along for the ride. Also, if it were live action, I probably wouldn't have been able to accept those crazy stunts that Snowy performed.  And like Hugo, the 3D did not feel gimicky in the slightest.

Conclusion - Spielberg & Jackson....more Tintin, please!  This is one franchise that may actually turn out well, provided that you guys don't drop the ball.  But don't pull an Indiana Jones on us.  No aliens.  Period.

"War Horse" (2011)


(NOT-SO-SUBTLE HINT: If you liked the movie, "abandon all hope ye who enter here"...which is from Dante's Inferno, in case you were wondering.)  Now, I will do my best to give this film a balanced review... *cough* ... as close to balanced as is humanly possible given my utter disappointment with this movie.

As my Dad (in a fit of critical brilliance) said coming out of the theater, the alternative title for War Horse should have been "Flicka Goes to War." (sidenote: My Friend Flicka was a popular boy-and-his-horse novel that got turned into a popular kids' TV program in the 1950s).  Why, do you ask, are you being so harsh on Spielberg, one of your favorite directors, Maddie?  Oh, I will most definitely tell you why.  Because I could smell the train wreck miles away.  And down the rabbit hole I go....

Ok.  First up - Story (because everything else flows from this).  Boy and his horse + war = does not a family film make.  It's not that it had to be a family film (although...horse movies tend to automatically lend themselves that category).  The horse and war themes were constantly at odds with each other, making the film schizophrenic in plot, characters, message, etc. You can't have your cake (horse/family film) and eat it (WWI), too.  You can only do justice to one at a time.  And since this film was marketed to families, Spielberg should have emphasized the boy-and-his-horse plot.  Yes, it pains me to say that WWI should have been the backdrop.  But if you're trying to make a true war film, you must do justice to the war and the men who served in it.  You must capture the magnitude of war through an intimate/emotional connection with the individuals who when through the hell.  Otherwise, throwing a horse (and his boy) in there and focusing on them trivializes the sacrifice of the millions who fought and died in it.  Seriously, (from the war film perspective) why the hell should I care about a horse at all?  Why am I being manipulated into an emotional connection with a freaking horse when there are soldiers screaming in agony in the middle of no-man's-land while their comrades listen helplessly?  That leaves a bad taste in your mouth.  Also, too many individual stories...focus in on the horse!

Adaptations from the Stage - Just to make sure we're all on the same page, War Horse was a successful stage play that Spielberg adapted into a screenplay.  I haven't seen the stage play yet, so I can't say whether or not it was better handled on stage.  But I can comment on the power of live performances.  After spending most of my childhood at the Detroit Opera House in operas or watching my Mom sing, I've learned that being there, being in the moment and feeling the emotions conveyed to you directly by the actors, can be far more gripping than film.  This is not to say that film can't be just as powerful.  But there is something to be said about experiencing emotions unmediated by editing, cinematography, and post-production finesse.  The stage (and the moment it creates)  also allows you to suspend reality in a way film cannot.  Film captures every little detail of "reality" (despite the fact that it is all illusion) and puts it right in front of your face.  You have a chance to distance yourself, rewatch it, critique it. From what I've heard from people who have seen the stage play War Horse, they say it is one of the best productions they've seen on stage.  Maybe that medium is far better for that story than the silver screen, where an emotionally-subtle play will probably (maybe inevitably?) be made into something sap-tastic. 

Acting/Characters - Steven Spielberg and Kathleen Kennedy attached a potentially great cast to War Horse, most of them being well-seasoned British thespians.  Problem: I say "potentially great" because I don't think it was the best they could do.  I can't really blame them...the screenplay was dripping with sappy cliches.  But maybe it wouldn't have come off as so cheesy had they been directed to be more subtle.  Come on, Spielberg, I've seen you do this so well before (E.T.) without being sappy...you have no excuse. 

Visuals - The cinematography was gorgeous (which what I've come to expect automatically from Spielberg).  Although...the ending scene when Albert and Joey return home had a sunset in the background that was way too reminiscent of Gone with the Wind.  You want to know one thing that did make me happy?  The in-camera visual effects.  This has been a year for bygone visual techniques to upstage fancy schmancy computer graphics.  I want more, please.

Soundtrack - When compared the entire body of John Williams' work, the War Horse score was not particularly memorable. As much as I love Williams's work, this does not surprise me.  He's almost 80 and near the end of his career. It was better than his other score this year, though.  Tintin was a (not-so-well) blended John Williams smoothie of every single score he's made.  And although it worked for that movie (sort of), War Horse had a much more unified and polished thematic structure that was tailored specifically to the emotions it was trying to convey. 

Whoa!  Hold on there!  I have one more thing to kvetch about before I move on to my conclusion. Maybe another reason I'm feeling angsty about this particular Spielberg film is because I'm a history major. And my favorite period to study is the 19th Century and WWI.  And I get really angry when Hollywood doesn't portray it accurately.  Now, please do not mistake me for some nit-picky history buff who will get mad about the fact that those belt buckles and buttons weren't used in the British army after 1916, or similar nonsense.  Despite some of the more apparent errors in the film, my concern lies more with how Spielberg portrayed the mentalities and moods of that era.  [spoiler] For instance, near the end of the movie, the horse gets stuck in the barbed wire in the middle of no-mans-land.  The Germans and the British sides are afraid to go help for fear of being shot by the other side.  Finally, one British soldier and one German soldier walk out from each side and agree to help each other free the horse.  The Germans lob over wire cutters to help with the process.  No one gets shot and a coin toss determines that the horse will go over to the British side.  There is no way in heck that the Brits and Germans would have done anything of the sort after fighting bitter trench warfare for several years. No way.  The horse would have been left to die or been shot by a sniper to put it out of its misery.  (Thanks for the 10 minute kvetch session, Dr. G!). 

In conclusion, this was the most disappointing movie I saw this year.  Maybe I went in with my expectations too high.  I was hoping that Hollywood would finally make a film that would at least portray WWI accurately, even if it was the backdrop to the main story. Oh well.  I guess it's up to me now...

"The Tree of Life" (2011)


[cue Bedrich Smetana's Die Moldau]

So, just so we're clear, I never saw The Tree of Life in theaters.  In fact, I had never even heard of the darn thing until several weeks after its limited release had ended. Word on the street had it that it was one of the best indie films to come out in 2011.  I had just finished The Wire and was feeling a gaping hole begin to form in my movie/TV-viewing life.  So I put The Tree of Life on my Netflix cue, waited until I was in the right mood for a philosophical headache (Hillsdale masochism), and bumped it up to #1 on the list.  The DVD arrived in the mail.  I chucked into my laptop, and so began a gorgeous ordeal.

The Tree of Life tells "[t]he impressionistic story of a Texas family in the 1950s. The film follows the life journey of the eldest son, Jack, through the innocence of childhood to his disillusioned adult years as he tries to reconcile a complicated relationship with his father (Brad Pitt). Jack (played as an adult by Sean Penn) finds himself a lost soul in the modern world, seeking answers to the origins and meaning of life while questioning the existence of faith" (IMDb).  I know that seems pretty straightforward (kind of), but please pay close attention to the word "impressionistic."  The nonlinear format of the story is initially off-putting, switching between scenes of a boy's life in the Midwest and grand images of the beginning of the universe.   It is simultaneously frustrating and magnificent.  And you know what?  It works.  Like an infuriatingly brilliant, highly-symbolic poem (that tortured you in your high-school English class), this is a film that forces you to grapple with the themes, think back and reflect.  It will teach you patience and discipline (hopefully) when it comes to movie-watching.

Fundamentally, The Tree of Life is a middle-aged Jack O'Brien being torn between the way of nature and the way of grace, demonstrated by Jack's father and mother respectively.  Mrs. O'Brien (grace) is gentle, nurturing, loving, kind, and tries to instill in her children a sense of wonder and awe for the world around them.  Her husband (nature) is incredibly strict and authoritarian, trying his best to prepare his sons for the world as he sees it--corrupt, exploitative, and Darwinistic.  Honestly, this is the first film I have seen that really grapples with these two views of world and does so effectively.

Tree of Life is filled to the brim with some stunning  cinematography and superb editing.  I don't know how they got some of the nature shots, but one particular scene sticks out in my memory.  Actress Jessica Chastain holds out her hand and a monarch butterfly lands on it.  And no, that was not computer generated.  Apparently, Chastain and Pitt spotted the butterfly and they (+ camera crew) followed it around for 3 blocks before it landed on Chastain.  That is dedication.  Also, the use of in-camera special effects makes me incredibly happy.  Director Terrence Malick wasn't very pleased with the way the computer-generated images for the creation of the universe, so he hired veteran special effects supervisor Douglas Trumbull (2001: A Space Odyssey, Close Encounters of the Third Kind and Blade Runner) to create those images using old school optical effects and long-forgotten techniques.  It was all chemistry and movie magic: fluid dynamics, fluorescent dyes, lighting, high-speed photography, smoke, flares, and everything else you could possibly imagine.  Trumbull created epic, absolutely gorgeous images of the cosmos, making it look far more believable than computer graphics.  He's my hero!

The acting was excellent.  Brad Pitt, Jessica Chastain, and Hunter McCracken made family life feel natural and realistic (causing the audience to feel like a bunch of voyeurs). You actually believe you are looking into a man's childhood in the Midwest.  Pitt and/or Chastain stand a very good chance of getting an Oscar for one of their supporting performances (although they are up against some pretty stiff competition this year).

Oh, and did I mention the amazing soundtrack?  Alexandre Desplat composed some original music for the film.  But what really made the soundtrack stand out from most of the other films this year was its use of well-known works by classical composers:  Smetana, Mahler, Gorecki, Berlioz, Respighi, Bach, Couperin, Brahms, Holst, etc.  The scenes set to Smetana's Die Moldau (the background music for the trailer) were particularly moving.  It's a gorgeous piece of music (one of my favorites, in fact) and I'm glad somebody finally used it well in a movie.

In the end, The Tree of Life is not a particularly fun movie to watch.  It's a beautifully-shot, well-acted, thought-provoking headache. Now if you ask the critics, they seem to be split right  down the middle, wavering between the adjectives of "brilliant" and "pretentious."  That's not surprising considering the fact that those are the two words the always seem to ascribe to indie films these days.  Again, not that this affects my opinion of it in the slightest, it did get an 84% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.  In a way, Tree of Life reminded me of watching Russian Ark - both movies are gorgeous ordeals that require discipline and effort, but they definitely are worth the patience it takes to watch them. It's like eating your cliche veggies.  So, go eat your cliche veggies. And make sure you listen to Smetana while you're at it.

"The Artist" (2011)

(image taken from Wikipedia)

When my parents and I went to the one art theater in metro-Detroit that was showing The Artist, we noticed that the it was packed (two to three times more people than the other 2 films I saw in MI theaters combined).  And although it is nearly impossible to imagine this happening in this day and age, this stunning French-produced silent film captured the audience's complete attention for an hour and a half.  Not one cell phone screen lit up.  No one talked.  Nobody shifted around with boredom in their seats.  I looked around during the middle of the movie and noticed that everyone was staring with rapt attention at the screen.  And that, my friends, is the mark of a great film. 

For the past two decades, studios and production companies have been stuffing their movies with gratuitous computer graphics, mostly to the detriment of the story. The Artist is a rare example of excellent story-telling that makes you wish such talent and vision were more commonplace (or maybe actually valued) in the Hollywood of today.  Let me give you a little background on the film's story and production first before I launch into a mini critique.  The story takes place in 1927 during the twilight of Hollywood's silent era.  "As silent movie star George Valentin wonders if the arrival of talking pictures will cause him to fade into oblivion, he sparks with Peppy Miller, a young dancer set for a big break" (IMDb).  This simple concept lends itself to a lot of depth in character development, dialogue, and nostalgia. And although the film's focus on the transition between silent era and talkies seems similar to Singin' in the Rain, Director Michel Hazanzvicius's (don't ask me to pronounce his last name) silent experiment feels fresh and original.

Acting - Jean Dujardin plays an arrogant, suave silent movie stud (a hybrid of Rudolph Valentino/Douglas Fairbanks with a dash of Errol Flynn) threatened by the advent of the talkies.  His comedic timing is impeccable, a quality that makes his slapstick style believable and funny.  Berenice Bejo plays Peppy Miller, an unknown upbeat dancer-turned-talkie-goddess who loves George.  The two have an onscreen chemistry that I haven't seen a leading man and lady since...well, a while...and it was an absolute delight to watch them play off of one another.  Best Actor and Actress.  Seriously.  I will be angry if they aren't at least nominated.  I've seen them in the hilarious French spy parody OSS 117: Cairo, Nest of  Thieves (2006), also directed by Michel Hazanavicius.  And let us not forget the wonderful supporting actors - John Goodman as studio exec/producer Al Zimmer and James Cromwell as loyal driver Clifton. 

Dialogue - Believe it or not, "dialogue" plays a rather important role. I know, it's a silent film. Between the dialogue cards and the actor's visual performance, every movement, thought, and emotion is perfectly and easily (and yes, even subtly) conveyed to the audience.  You never miss a thing. 

Mise en Scene / Cinematography / Editing - Simply gorgeous.  Just look at the poster.  The lighting makes the film glow, giving it a radiance reminiscent of the glory days of the silver screen.  And the shots?  Fantastic and well thought out.  Also, the editing really enhanced the comedic timing.     
Sound/Score -  Most of the film lacks sound (duh!  It's a silent film) - the only thing you hear is the score.  However (without giving too much away), Hazanavivius uses sounds in a dream sequence and the finale to to highlight the conflict/tension/transition between the silent era and the dawn of talking pictures.  Ludovic Bource composed a mostly-original score that was reminiscent of silent-era scores.  The score added to the film (as opposed to being neutral or a detriment).  The only exception would be his quotation of Bernard Hermann's love theme from Hitchcock's Vertigo.  Kim Novak (who played Jimmy Stewart's love interest) is livid about this.  Eh.  I really don't have a huge issue with it, but I do understand her point.  She feels that such borrowing is cheating, stealing the emotions that Hermann had worked hard to evoke in the original scene and trying to make it their own.  And most of the movie-going public wouldn't pick up on the fact that it's a quotation.  I wish Bource had written his own music instead, but that doesn't ruin my love for the film. 

Although I normally don't care what the critics think, Rotten Tomatoes rates this movie at 97%, which (may I point out) is absolutely unheard of.  I think the beautifully-lit poster captures the essence of the film: warmth, charm and class (ironically, the three qualities Hollywood has been lacking in most of its features these days). The 50 people who showed up to Maple Art Theater seemed to be sick of hollow characters who lack humanity, aimless plots, glitzy computer graphics and sensory-overload (Michael Bay explosions, anyone?).   The Artist paid great homage to a bygone era, never once slipping into parody, derision or even idealization and it gives me some hope that there are still great story-tellers and originality out there. I'm calling this one.  I think this could very well be 2011's Best Picture.  I hope the Academy won't let me down.

Friday, December 30, 2011

Excuses, Excuses

(Belated) Merry Christmas and (Preemptive) Happy New Year!  I have been terrible at keeping up with my blog over the past month.  Now hold on a second.  Before you start kvetching, I have a legitimate excuse (or maybe several).  First, the temp agency gave me a 2-week job as a gift-wrapper in a mailroom just before my long-awaited 2.5 week Christmas/New Years trip to see my parents in metro-Detroit.  The days were long (but fun) and left me way too tired to come up with anything creative. Then the few days between the temp job and my flight were filled with Maran's long-awaited return to Luckenbooth, saying goodbye to LA friends (for only a brief period of time, of course), and a densely-packed succession of Christmas parties.  And now that I am home, I've been enjoying my time with my wonderful parents and old friends.

As you can probably guess, blogging has been low on the list of recent priorities.  I'm sorry.  I've been a bad blogger.  But sometimes you need to stop writing about life and just live it.  However, I will make it up to you in the coming weeks (as I am itching to write again).   First, I will (eventually) get around to another (probably belated December/third) entry for our TGT series (brain is not functioning properly, so I may have to do TGT # 3 & 4 at about the same time).  Then, I've got some movies to review: The Tree of Life, Hugo, The Artist, War Horse, and The Adventures of TinTin.  And, of course, I will come up with my usual array of unusual topics. For now, I will leave you with this amazing picture of Victor Ricardo:

("Only one thing in the world could've dragged me away from 
the soft glow of electric sex gleaming in the window.") 
Ralphie (Jean Shepherd), A Christmas Story

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

"Forgetfulness" (Billy Collins)

The name of the author is the first to go
followed obediently by the title, the plot,
the heartbreaking conclusion, the entire novel
which suddenly becomes one you have never read,
never even heard of,

as it, one by one, the memories you used to harbor
decided to retire to the southern hemisphere of the brain,
to a little fishing village where there are no phones.

Long ago you kissed the names of the nine Muses goodbye
and watched the quadratic equation pack its bag,
and even now as you memorize the order of the planets,

something else is slipping away, a state flower perhaps,
the address of an uncle, the capital of Paraguay.

Whatever it is you are struggling to remember,
it is not poised on the top of your tongue,
not even lurking in some obscure corner of your spleen.

It has floated away down a dark mythological rivier
whose name begins with an L as far as you can recall,
well on your own way to oblivion where will join those
who have even forgotten how to swim and how to ride a bicycle.

No wonder you rise in the middle of the night
to look up the date of a famous battle in a book on war.
No wonder the moon in the window seems to have drifted
out of a love poem that you used to know by heart.



[Thanks for sharing, Roddy.]

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

TGT #2 - Xenophon & Underwater Basket Weaving

OK folks - it's that time of the month again, when I make myself feel incredibly stupid by publishing some half-baked thoughts on the ingenious musings of far more brilliant men. So what didn't Xenophon do?  His resume puts mine to shame: soldier, historian, essayist, Athenian veteran of the Peloponnesian War.  Why Maddie?  Why must you do this to yourself?  Because it's about the higher things!  And they scream out to me on a fairly regular basis.  Unfortunately, my friends, this will probably not end up being a particularly coherent essay.  Greek writers tend to do that to me.  Where will I end up this time?  Well, let's get on with it...

The early Greeks seem to be obsessed about this thing they call (or at least our translator calls) "excellence."  I have a vague notion of what they are getting at there, but I'll move on to other things.  When talking of Socrates, Xenophon starts off with this:
"Thus he [Socrates] would often say he was 'in love'; but clearly his heart was not set on those who were fair to outward view, but those whose souls excelled in goodness.  These excellent beings he recognized by their quickness to learn whatever subject they studied, ability to remember what they learned, and desire for every kind of knowledge on which depend good management of a household and estate and tactful dealing with men and the affairs of men.  For education would make such beings not only happy in themselves, and successful in the management of their households, but capable of conferring happiness on their fellow-men and on states alike" (TGT 30).  
He seems to be linking education and happiness.  Education isn't always rainbows and fuzzy bunnies - it opens your eyes to some of the bleaker aspects of human nature and the human condition.  However, a true education sets your mind ablaze and lifts you up to an entirely new world of understanding.  And in that you can be happy.  You constantly hunger for more and more to fill that insatiable intellectual appetite.  I've experienced this at Hillsdale - once you get a taste of it, you never go back.  All of the sudden, you come back home for Christmas and get really excited about receiving The Great Tradition as your present rather than a Best Buy gift card.  Also, if "conferring happiness" means "pass down what you have learned," then I am all for that.  But I'm not sure that's what Xenophon is going for there...

On the next page (TGT 31), Xenophon launches into some argument with a pompous ass about his indebtedness to the past for his knowledge.  Woot!  Way to go, Xenophon!  Also, on page 37, he tells us about how Socrates urged his followers to be well-rounded.  Yay for the liberal arts!  Huzzah!

There's some other stuff and then we hit 35, a page that contains the infamous words "know thyself."  This is probably one of the most misquoted phrases EVER (besides "ideas have consequences.")  The modern world likes to twist it around into empty phrases like that inane Disney message of "be you true self and who you were truly mean to be (a rock star, duh!) and everything will be super-special awesome!"  What the heck does any of that claptrap mean?  I'm sorry, but Miley Cyrus/Hannah Montana and Selena Gomez do not impress me with their "selfness."  To the Greeks, it meant know your abilities and limitations.  It's an important self-examination that we like to gloss over in modernity.  We often tell people that they should refuse to be held back by any limitations, even ones inherent in their nature/being.  Or we're told that our abilities are way more amazing than they actually are.  This leads to a lot of frustration and anger, especially with kids in my generation who were given participation trophies for underwater basket weaving and then told that all of us could be rock stars or corporate executives.  We have built up our self-esteem at the cost of taking an honest look in the mirror.  We ignore what we really are so we can be something we're not.  Basically, Socrates' two-word phrase warns that same pompous ass against boasting.  We boast much about nothing these days....and are the unhappier for it. 

Did any of what I just wrote make sense?  Don't care - must. publish. article.  OK - enough incoherent babbling.  I'm going to finish off with another theme Xenophon seemed particularly fond of: don't specialize - it's bad.  The End.